Archive | Clergy Abuse

Federal Bankruptcy Judge in Delaware Approves $77 Million Settlement for Abuse Victims Against the Roman Catholic Diocese of Wilmington

Federal Bankruptcy Judge in Delaware Approves $77 Million Settlement for Abuse Victims Against the Roman Catholic Diocese of Wilmington

By MICHELE BETTI | b&a opinions

As a mechanism for evading liability, the Diocese of Wilmington, Delaware filed its Chapter 11 bankruptcy petition October 18, 2009. Recently, a federal bankruptcy judge in Delaware approved a $77 million settlement for child sexual abuse victims against the Roman Catholic Diocese of Wilmington.

Confirming a reorganization plan for the Roman Catholic Diocese of Wilmington, the judge approved the $77 million settlement for nearly 150 alleged victims of child sexual abuse. Each victim will receive an average of $530,000 under the settlement. A court order signed Thursday by Judge Christopher Sontchi will release the Diocese from all further litigation related to the sexual abuse scandal.

The lawsuits against the Diocese were filed after a state law created a two-year window for claims of abuse to be brought regardless of whether the statute of limitations had expired.

Delaware is a state that has instituted a no limit on statute of limitations on child sexual abuse. Something that other states like New York and Hawaii have attempted to do, but have been openly opposed by the Catholic Church, and many other secular and non-secular institutions that vehemently oppose open statute of limitations on child sexual abuse.

The Diocese of Wilmington Delaware is the seventh of eight Roman Catholic Dioceses to file for Chapter 11 protection to deal with lawsuits for sexual abuse.

The case is In re Catholic Diocese of Wilmington, 09-13560, U.S. Bankruptcy Court, District of Delaware, (Wilmington).

Copyright 2011, b&a opinions.

Posted in Clergy Abuse1 Comment

Why Are The Names Of Sex Offender Priests Being Redacted From Cardinal Mahoney’s Deposition Transcript?

Why Are The Names Of Sex Offender Priests Being Redacted From Cardinal Mahoney’s Deposition Transcript?

California, clergy sexual abuse, Roman Catholic, Cardinal Mahony, Los Angeles Archdiocese, cover-up, predator priest, sex offender

Why Are The Names Of Sex Offender Priests Being Redacted From Cardinal Mahoney’s Deposition Transcript?
By MICHELE BETTI | b&a opinions

Why are the names of sex offender predator priests being redacted from the deposition transcript of Archbishop Roger Mahony?  Such action given the documented collusion of those in authority in protecting and covering up for sexually abusive clerics is troubling.  Mahoney, Bishop of the Archdiocese of Los Angeles provided deposition testimony under oath a few weeks ago.  Several priests who were accused and convicted of child molestation have their names redacted from the transcript.  An excerpt from the transcript reads as follows:

Q: Okay, 1985 or ’86 he [sex offender priest name redacted] was arrested and charged with child molestation, does that sound right?

A: Somewhere in that time frame?

Q: Does it help refresh your recollection if I represent to you he was accused of putting his hands and touching the genitals of high school seminarians while they were in bed at Our Lady Queen of Angels Seminary?

A: Yes.

Q: So he was accused of touching and did go to jail?

A: I don’t recall.

Bishops in Connecticut, Florida, New York, Ohio and Pennsylvania have done everything possible to keep Child Victims Acts addressing child abuse legislation from being passed.  Bishops have adamantly opposed any legislation that would change statutes of limitations that prevent child victims from seeking redress shortly after they turn 18.

It has been eight years since the U.S. Catholic church was rocked to its foundations by revelations of clergy sex abuse in the Boston archdiocese.  And five years since a Philadelphia grand jury released a report documenting in explicit detail decades of abuse by clergy and cover up by the Philadelphia archdiocese.

Still church leaders continue to protect the molesters.  And church leaders continue to place blame on the messengers rather than on themselves.  The system has become so corrupted that it puts the protection of individual sexual predators along with an institution’s reputation before the protection of its most vulnerable flock – the children.

Copyright 2010, b&a opinions.

Posted in Clergy Abuse, Featured0 Comments

Who is in Donald Wuerl’s Back Pocket, and Why?

Who is in Donald Wuerl’s Back Pocket, and Why?

Guest Contribution August 17, 2:28 PMPittsburgh Independent ExaminerMike Ference
Southwestern PA has the nation’s 18th largest Catholic population per capita, making the Catholic presence here as significant as it is in #17 Los Angeles, #12 New York, and #11 Boston. That was reason enough for Donald Wuerl to cover up the offenses of sexually abusive priests. But how could such a thing be done? Well, one must speculate that, for a cover-up to be undertaken and sustained, only unscrupulous elected officials and less-than-honest law enforcement officers – with perhaps ties to organized crime – would have to be in Donald Wuerl’s back pocket, if not in his pocketbook. Would such a thing even be possible? Imagine, street-smart thugs partnering with a frail, effeminate, and pint-sized creature such as Donald Wuerl, with one goal in mind – to protect dysfunctional sex freaks who used innocent children as sex toys. Let’s look at the facts:

Wuerl was trained by an alleged master of sexual preying, namely, the former Bishop of Pittsburgh, John Cardinal Wright. It should be noted that Wright was hauled off to Rome once the Richard Ginder scandal began to unfold. This is what happened to Bernard Law of Boston, once his cover-ups made headline news. Now, concerning Father Richard Ginder, he was a flamboyant homosexual and notorious pedophile who would eventually die under mysterious circumstances. Furthermore, it was discovered that he had an apartment in Shadyside, Pennsylvania. It was then discovered that he harbored child pornography in that apartment.

Concerning Donald Wuerl, he spent 10 years under the tutelage of Wright in Rome, where, according to a nationally published third party, Wuerl’s network of like-minded homosexual prelates began to form. Caring for a sickly Cardinal Wright in 1978 allowed Wuerl to be the only non-red-hat at the conclave that resulted in Karol Józef Wojtya being elected the new leader of the Catholic Church. Years later, the two persons would join forces again, when Wuerl would insistently object to the Vatican’s decision to have Father Anthony Cippolla be reinstated as a priest in good standing. Wuerl’s theatrics would prevail. The pope would approve the reversal of the church’s highest court (concerning the Cipolla case) and Donald Wuerl would make sure that everyone would know about it. This resulted in Wuerl gaining the reputation of a heroic bishop who had zero tolerance for clergy abuse.
Donald Wuerl’s Documented Cover-ups are Soon to be Presented, Here
As will soon be illustrated by a guest writer, the hero status of Donald Wuerl is hogwash. Wuerl had a self-seeking motive for pursuing the Cipolla case to the end, and he also had a number of sex abuse cover-ups which eventually found their ways onto one type of court docket or another; including that of criminal court. Furthermore, Wuerl has been and continues to be a catalyst for the homosexual community. Sadly enough, Wuerl has been proven to be nothing more than another figure in the Catholic Church’s hierarchy who is more than willing to cover up clergy sex abuses. Wuerl is also said to closely resemble one of Wright’s former play toys, thereby suggesting that Wright’s choice of Wuerl as personal secretary was made for reasons other than professional competency.
Donald Wuerl’s Support System While He Was in the Pittsburgh Diocese
Former Supreme Court Chief Justices Stephen Zappala and David Cappy served on Wuerl’s legal advisory committee, along with 12 to 36 high-profile Pittsburgh attorneys. It would have been virtually impossible for a family to file a lawsuit against the diocese without Wuerl getting wind of it shortly after it was filed, and maybe even sooner.
For whatever it’s worth, Stephen Zappala Jr., current district attorney for the Allegheny County which encompasses much of Wuerl’s former terrain, has been appointed by the President of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) to a three-year term on the National Review Board. His term is to begin on June 1, 2010. Such board members collaborate with the USCCB in safeguarding minors from the sexual abuse of those dysfunctional sex freaks who have been placed in the service of the church. Ironically, Donald Wuerl is expected to receive a cardinal’s hat in June 2010, due to Cardinal McCarrick turning 80 years of age that month.
Zappala’s office has never prosecuted a clergy abuse case, and it has steadfastly refused to conduct a grand jury investigation into Pittsburgh area clergy abuse. Yet, the Philadelphia district attorney’s office held its own grand jury investigation into the Archdiocese of Philadelphia, ultimately issuing a scathing report that identified dozens of Catholic clerics who were guilty of heinous crimes against innocent children, while acknowledging the widespread cover-ups of archdiocesan leaders who protected the criminals instead of the victims who endured every imaginable form of sexual and physical abuse. The grand jury would label Anthony Bevilacqua a liar. Bevilacqua was the former Bishop of Pittsburgh. Insiders openly admit that Bevilacqua left quite a mess for Donald Wuerl to deal with, once Wuerl took over the Diocese of Pittsburgh.
The Recent Kickback Scheme
Is D.A. Stephen Zappala Jr. the right choice for preventing sexual abuse from occurring in an institution (the Catholic Church) that has been marked by widespread abuse and the subsequent cover-ups that appear to have been the accepted norm for a succession of bishops, cardinals, and popes? Recently, the D.A.’s brother, Gregory Zappala, was and may still be part of a probe involving two former Pennsylvania judges who knowingly sentenced juveniles to private detention facilities owned by Gregory Zappala, in exchange for $2.6 million in kickbacks. Over 5,000 children were sent to these homes, not because they were hardened criminals, but because in Pennsylvania – the pro-pedophile state – children have very little worth and can be exploited at every opportunity. These 5,000+ children were incarcerated for crimes such as truancy and stealing change out of parked cars – with neither legal counsel nor parents present, at times.
Originally, Gregory Zappala’s partner, John Powell, claimed that he was a victim of extortion. He has since come to his senses and pled guilty, as he will now serve time for the felonies he committed. Interestingly enough, this convicted felon claims that his former partner, Gregory Zappala, knew nothing about the kickback scheme. Quite frankly, are we to believe that a person who profited from judicial fraud is telling the truth this one time?
While Steven Zappala would argue that his little brother was the victim of a convoluted cash-for-kids plot, anyone with an I.Q. over 50 could easily argue that a seasoned financial wiz like Gregory Zappala (who has a retired PA Supreme Court Chief Justice for a dad and the district attorney of the second largest county in Pennsylvania for a brother) would be the last person to target for extortion, let alone claim to have been a victim? I’m not so sure that Stephen Zappala has the right heart or soul to reconcile the types of claims a supposedly objective member of the USCCB National Review Board would be required to address. Zappala’s appointment only adds accelerant to the search for a smoldering gun that seems to now be in reach.
Back to Shadyside Hospital
Shadyside Hospital officials knowingly covered up the crimes of John Wellinger which included feeding drugs and alcohol to an underage boy until he sank into an unconscious state. I recently sent my findings to the Pennsylvania Department of Health, and here is there response in a nutshell, provided by Andrea Beeler, R.N. Health Quality Administer:
The Department of Health, through the Office of Quality Assurance, is responsible for establishing and enforcing the standards that protect the health and safety of all patients who seek treatment within our Commonwealth. She goes on to write that, as per our telephone conversation, my concerns about the police and the Pittsburgh Catholic Diocese are beyond the purview of the department. But, what about my claim against the Shadyside Hospital administrators who hid the actions of a Pittsburgh Catholic priest from law enforcement authorities? The fix is still in. No recommendations on who might be able to help or what other agency might be able to handle this type of complaint. Again, welcome to PA – the pro-pedophile and ephebophile-friendly State.
A Recent Disclosure, Confided to me Shortly after the Brother Kenneth Ghastin Discovery
Recently, I learned from a very reliable source that a certain Pittsburgh hospital has been covering the homosexuality of a former Pittsburgh Catholic bishop. According to my source, the administrators were detailing the need to continue the cover-up, mentioning how important it was for this type of information to never leak out. Pittsburgh is certainly the right place for these types of secret agreements among hospital administrators.
Also, there may be more victims of clergy sexual abuse dating back to the time when Brother Ghastin and other Franciscan clergy members were assigned to Serra Catholic High School in McKeesport, PA. Could the City of McKeesport and its police department be responsible for covering up even more crimes against underage children?
Anyone with additional information on this report or on similar events is welcomed to send a message to my email address, Ference@icubed.com, or to call me at 412-233-5491.
Reporting live from Pittsburgh’s Golden Triangle – where the confluence of the Sicilian mob and the Democratic Party meet to form the deMOBocrats.
To read my June 5th article, Is Stephen Zappala the right choice Cardinal George?, go to:
To read my June 12th article, Citizen Investigator Won’t Be Silenced, go to:
About the Author:
Mike Ference is an entrepreneur, writer, speaker and investigative reporter who has been probing clergy abuse and government corruption in Pennsylvania for almost 20 years. Mike may be reached at 412-233-5491 or email him at Ference@icubed.com.

Posted in Clergy Abuse0 Comments

Betti & Associates Philadelphia Press Coverage On priest-uncle abuse case

Betti & Associates Philadelphia Press Coverage On priest-uncle abuse case

Man tells of abuse by priest-uncle

By DAFNEY TALES
Philadelphia Daily News

talesd@phillynews.com 215-854-5084

NOTE: THIS STORY HAS BEEN CORRECTED.

It was the middle of the night when a young John Katubi was roused by someone who slipped into bed with him.

It was his uncle, the Rev. Robert Gaghan, a parish priest and teacher, who Katubi said fondled him under the covers and then performed oral sex on him.

Katubi said it happened that one time, but since then, his life had been wrought with emotional distress, an overwhelming sense of guilt and substance abuse. Now, Katubi, 64, a divorced father who lives in Florida, is trying to pick up the pieces.

“I realized I had problems, but the cause [for them] I realized about a year ago,” he said yesterday at a demonstration outside Saints John Neumann and Maria Goretti High School, in South Philadelphia. He had attended Neumann years after his abuse, where Gaghan taught. Neumann and Goretti merged in 2004.

“I thought this was some kind of initiation that I didn’t know about,” he said.

A handful of supporters joined him yesterday outside the school, at 10th and Morris streets, to request that school officials inform alumni about Gaghan and to encourage possible victims to come forward. Katubi didn’t tell anyone of his abuse until 2008, when he reported the incident to Daylesford Abbey, in Paoli, run by the Norbertines, who supervised Gaghan before his death in 1989.

An investigation “determined that Mr. Katubi’s allegation of sexual abuse by the Rev. Robert Gaghan was credible,” a statement released by an abbey spokesman said yesterday.

Officials had offered Katubi assistance with counseling, the statement further reads. But their offer, which Katubi’s lawyer, Michelle Betti, said was $2,000 per year for 10 years, was unsatisfactory.

It’s not enough because he believes that his uncle, who died of liver disease, may have molested more boys. His younger brother Robert had admitted to being another one of his alleged victims. His other brother, Andrew, he said, was abused by a friend of their uncle’s, also a priest. Both later died of drug overdoses, he said.

Outside the school, Patricia Sticco, Neumann-Goretti principal, sympathized with Katubi.

“I’m sorry for what happened to you,” she said to him before shaking his hand. She referred media inquiries to the Archdiocese of Philadelphia. Archdiocese spokeswoman Donna Farrell urged abuse victims to contact the Victims’ Assistance Office at 888-800-8780 or at phila vac@adphila.org.


CORRECTION:

A story in yesterday’s Daily News incorrectly identified the religious order of a priest accused of abuse many years ago and the order that runs Daylesford Abbey, in Paoli. The Abbey is run by Norbertines and Rev. Robert Gaghan was a Norbertine, not a Vincentian.

Posted in Clergy Abuse0 Comments

Irish Catholic abusers and those covered up crimes – Examiner

Irish Catholic abusers and those covered up crimes – Examiner

War tactics should be applied to Irish Catholic abusers and those covered up crimes

By Mike Ference

Every day brings new evidence that we no longer live in a civilized and principled society. The worst part, it usually concerns another case of sexual misconduct involving a Catholic priest, young children and a church hierarchy that helped to cover up the case.

The recently unveiled 2,600-page report by the Irish Commission explaining the systematic practice of torture and molestation at the country’s labor and educational institutions run by the Catholic Church for decades clearly suggests that Catholic Church Hierarchy have certainly outlived any usefulness to society.
And they still deny the heinous crimes and expect their weekly bounty of donations. But as more and more cases of abuse — and cover-up — come to light, one begins to wonder whether the Pope and his entourage of red hats should be considered any more trustworthy than, say, Saddam Hussein.

So — what should be done now that we know it’s a pattern of terror orchestrated by the Catholic Church and repeated everywhere the dysfunctional sex freaks have established a church, school, hospital or other institution. Given the level of wreckage and anguish caused in the lives of so many people, it seems appropriate to look to the war on terror for a model strategy.

Click on the link below or cut and paste into your browser for the rest of the story
http://www.examiner.com/x-12613-Pittsburgh-Independent-Examiner~y2009m6d3-War-tactics-should-be-applied-to-Irish-Catholic-abusers-and-those-who-covered-up-crimes

examaner_mikeferenceMike Ference is an entrepreneur, writer, speaker and investigative reporter who has been probing clergy abuse and government corruption in Pennsylvania for almost 20 years. Mike may be reached at 412-233-5491 or email him at Ference@icubed.com.

Posted in Clergy Abuse0 Comments

Case Opinion: Physical and Child Sexual Clergy Abuse in Ireland Inquiry

Case Opinion: Physical and Child Sexual Clergy Abuse in Ireland Inquiry

Physical and Child Sexual Abuse in Ireland was endemic between 1940 and the late 1970s

July 27, 2009: A report released May 20 by the Irish State Commission of Inquiry reveals child sexual abuse was rampant in Ireland

By MICHELE BETTI | b&f opinions July 27, 2009

The Irish government established an independent commission in 2000 to hear evidence from anyone alleged to have suffered child abuse at institutions since 1940. These institutions, funded by the state, but often run by Catholic religious orders, included schools, orphanages, hospitals, children’s homes or any other institutions where children were in the care of non-family members.

As you read excerpts from the report below you will see ten similarities that often occur in child sexual abuse cases today. They include:

  1. When confronted with evidence of sexual abuse, the response of the religious authorities was to transfer the offender to another location where, in many instances, he was free to abuse again.
  2. Abusers were moved, but nothing was done about the harm done to the child.
  3. Authoritarian management systems prevented disclosures by staff and served to perpetuate abuse.
  4. Lack of transparency in how the matter of sexual abuse was dealt with between the Congregations, dioceses and the Department.
  5. Men with histories of sexual abuse when they were members of religious Orders continued their teaching careers as lay teachers in State schools.
  6. The Department of Education dealt inadequately with complaints about sexual abuse.

These complaints were generally dismissed or ignored. Continue Reading

Posted in Clergy Abuse, Featured, Sexual Abuse Case Opinions2 Comments

Voice of the Faithful Supporting Survivors Of Clergy Sexual Abuse Advocating Change Within The Church

Voice of the Faithful Supporting Survivors Of Clergy Sexual Abuse Advocating Change Within The Church

July 23, 2009:  Voice of the Faithful, a Lay Catholic Group Founded in 2002 During the Boston Clergy Sex Abuse Scandal, Faces Financial Crisis

By MICHELE BETTI | b&f opinions July 25, 2009

A lay Catholic group, based in the Boston suburb of Needham, founded in 2002 in the wake of the church’s clergy sex abuse scandal said it may be forced to cease operations because of a downturn in donations.

Voice of the Faithful was founded in 2002 during the clergy sex abuse crisis with the mission of giving lay people a greater role in the Catholic Church.  The group’s goals are to support survivors of clergy sexual abuse; support priests of integrity; and shape structural change within the Catholic Church. Continue Reading

Posted in Child Sexual Abuse News, Clergy Abuse1 Comment

Child Sexual Abuse in Ireland was endemic 1940 and the late 1970s

Child Sexual Abuse in Ireland was endemic 1940 and the late 1970s

Physical and Child Sexual Abuse in Ireland was endemic between 1940 and the late 1970s – Report by the Irish State Commission of Inquiry.

July 24, 2009:  A report released May 20 by the Irish State Commission of Inquiry reveals child sexual abuse was rampant in Ireland

By MICHELE BETTI Attorney| b&f opinions July 24, 2009

The Irish government established an independent commission in 2000 to hear evidence from anyone alleged to have suffered child abuse at institutions since 1940.  These institutions, funded by the state, but often run by Catholic religious orders, included schools, orphanages, hospitals, children’s homes or any other institutions where children were in the care of non-family members.

As you read excerpts from the report below you will see ten similarities that often occur in child sexual abuse cases today. They include: Continue Reading

Posted in Child Sexual Abuse News, Clergy Abuse0 Comments


Contact Betti & Associates Law

Betti & Associates – Lawyers Representing Victims of Sexual Abuse Cases

Law Offices & Practice Locations:

California – New York – Illinois – Florida – New Jersey – Pennsylvania – Delaware – Hawaii

Areas of Practice In Child Abuse Law:
  • --Clergy Sexual Abuse
  • --Boy Scout Sexual Abuse
  • --Sexually Abused in School
  • --Child Abuse by Authority Figure
  • --Complex Civil Litigation
Contact us to schedule a Confidential Consultation

Connect With Betti & Associates

Attorney Michele Betti  of Betti and Associates Linked In

Facebook